Four green leather bar stools with four cocktails at a moody wooden bar

The Four Authors Living in My Head (And Why They Should Probably Be Supervised)

A getaway driver, a medical examiner, and a woman who solves her problems with a frying pan walk into a bar.

I'd read that book.

Last night I decided to figure out why four authors who have absolutely no business sharing space in my head are among my all-time favorites. After a lifetime of writing books, I thought it was probably time to examine my own questionable taste.

S.A. Cosby writes Southern noir full of blood, grief, and people making terrible decisions for reasons you completely understand. Karin Slaughter writes crime fiction that will rip your heart out, stomp on it, and leave you counting the days until her next book. And Jennifer Crusie and Bob Mayer write romantic thrillers full of smart women, dangerous men, spectacular banter, and an alarming number of dead people.

I've read hundreds of authors over the years, and there are plenty I admire. But these four are automatic buys. I don't need to read the blurb. I don't need to know what the book is about. Just take my money.

So I started looking at what they have in common, and why their books work so well for me.

First, the voice. Oh, the voice.

I can open a book by any of them to a random page and know whose book I'm reading.

Cosby has a rhythm that's entirely his own. His characters can be brutal, tender, funny, and furious, sometimes in the same conversation. Slaughter can describe something absolutely horrifying with such matter-of-fact precision that it becomes even more horrifying. Jenny and Bob write characters who could argue about a grocery list and I'd happily read twenty pages of it.

These writers have opinions. Their characters have opinions. Everybody has opinions, and some of those people have guns.

I love that.

Second, their characters are really, really good at something.

Take Beauregard in Cosby's Blacktop Wasteland. The man can drive. Unfortunately, being an extraordinarily talented getaway driver tends to attract the wrong kind of attention.

Will Trent is a brilliant investigator who struggles with dyslexia. He can see things other investigators miss, even when reading a case file presents its own challenges.

And Jenny and Bob have practically perfected the art of putting a smart, mouthy, competent woman together with a man who knows his way around a weapon and a bad situation, then giving them a corpse to deal with. Agnes and the Hitman is a perfect example. So are Don't Look Down and Wild Ride, along with their Liz Danger books (Lavender's Blue, Rest in Pink, One in Vermillion) and the Rocky Start books (Rocky Start, Very Nice Funerals, The Honey Pot Plot), plus the Rocky Road novella.

I love competent characters. Especially competent women. Give me a woman who can assess a terrible situation, make a plan, and then improvise when the plan goes spectacularly sideways.

Competence pointed in a slightly crooked direction is catnip with a side of tequila.

Third, they're funny. Yes, even Cosby and Slaughter.

This might be the thing that surprised me most when I started thinking about it.

Cosby writes some of the darkest crime fiction I've ever read. Slaughter has put me through things I still haven't forgiven her for. But both of them are funny.

Their characters use humor the way real people do when things are going horribly wrong. They get sarcastic. They say inappropriate things. They make jokes because the alternative is screaming, and screaming isn't going to help much.

Jenny and Bob write the same thing with the lights on.

Their books are often hilarious, but the danger is real. People die. People get hurt. Bad things happen to people you like. And somehow the humor makes you care about them even more.

I've always believed that dark stories need humor. I want to laugh in the middle of a terrible situation, even if I feel a little guilty about it.

Actually, especially then.

Fourth, their relationships are complicated. Gloriously complicated.

This is where I think all four authors really shine, and it's probably the biggest reason their books stay with me.

Take Razorblade Tears. Two fathers set out to avenge their murdered sons, but there's so much going on underneath that revenge story. These are men who failed their sons in different ways, who have to confront their own prejudices and regrets, and who develop a complicated bond with each other along the way. There's parental love, romantic love, loyalty, shame, grief, friendship, and the awful realization that you can't go back and fix what you should have done while someone was alive.

I could write an entire post about the relationships in that book alone.

And Karin Slaughter. Good grief.

I love Will Trent and Sara Linton. (Excellent name for a heroine, by the way. No notes.) But two of my absolute favorite Slaughter books are Pretty Girls and The Good Daughter.

Pretty Girls digs into the wreckage left behind when a family loses a daughter and sister, and the secrets and betrayals that grow out of that loss. The Good Daughter is another master class in complicated family relationships. Sisters who have lived through the same terrible event but carry it differently. Parents who love their children and still manage to hurt them. Marriages, loyalties, resentments, and decades of emotional baggage.

And the screen adaptation of The Good Daughter is currently one of the best things you can watch. Seriously. Watch it.

Jenny and Bob bring that same complexity to their books, although you're considerably more likely to laugh while reading them. Their characters come with families, exes, old grudges, friendships, obligations, and entire towns full of people who have opinions about their lives. The romantic relationships are wonderful, but so are all the other connections that make their characters who they are.

I love this stuff. Give me people who adore each other and drive each other crazy. People who are loyal to someone who doesn't deserve it. Families with secrets, friendships tested by terrible decisions, and relationships that change under pressure.

The body count sits on the surface. Underneath are all the relationships that make those deaths matter.

And here's a fun bit of personal history. My agents once told me I write sex well, humor well, and thrills well, but I suck at romance.

Fair assessment, frankly.

I'm fascinated by relationships, including romantic ones. I'm just much better at putting people through hell together than getting them to a happily-ever-after.

Which may explain a few things about my career choices.

Fifth, bad things have consequences.

Karin Slaughter killed off a beloved character years ago, and readers are still mad about it. I'm not naming names because some of you haven't read those books yet, and I refuse to be responsible for that particular trauma.

Cosby's characters carry the consequences of violence long after the shooting stops. People don't just get up, dust themselves off, and go back to normal.

Even Jenny and Bob, who are perfectly happy to make you laugh until you snort, understand that murder is a serious business. Their characters may be funny, but they're in genuine danger.

I appreciate writers who aren't afraid to hurt their characters.

Obviously.

Sixth, I want to live in their worlds. With certain precautions.

Cosby's small Virginia towns are full of history, grudges, loyalty, and people who remember what your grandfather did in 1962.

Slaughter's Grant County and Atlanta feel real enough that I could probably find my way around. I'd just avoid dark alleys. And parking garages. And possibly Georgia altogether.

Jenny and Bob create small towns full of meddlers, eccentrics, complicated families, and people who know your business before you do. I'd move to one tomorrow, although I'd probably want to check the local homicide statistics first.

I love books that make a place feel like another character. I want to know the streets, the businesses, the neighbors, and which houses I should avoid after dark.

And finally, they trust their readers.

They don't explain every emotion or tell you what you're supposed to think about a character. They give you complicated people doing complicated things and let you make up your own mind.

Sometimes you love someone you probably shouldn't. Sometimes you understand a terrible decision. Sometimes you realize you were rooting for the wrong person.

I love when a writer gives me enough credit to figure that out for myself.

And after spending an evening analyzing all this, I realized something. These are exactly the qualities I aspire to bring to my own books. The distinctive voices, the humor, the complicated relationships, the characters who stay with you, and the consequences that matter.

I'm certainly not claiming to write at their level. These four are in a league of their own, and I'll be delighted if I ever get close.

But that's the bar I'm aiming for.

A getaway driver, a medical examiner, and a woman with a frying pan walk into a bar.

Someday I'd love for one of my characters to pull up a stool beside them.

Preferably with a dog at her feet.

Now I'd love to hear about the authors living in your head. Especially the combinations that make absolutely no sense until you start thinking about them.

Tell me in the comments. I'm always looking for another author to love, although at this point the accommodations in my head are getting a little crowded.

Sara

Back to blog